Article 13: The End Of The Internet As We Know It?
In this guest post, CEO and founder of The Flaxen Liz Ferguson explains why EU Article 13 will impact everyone who uploads content to social platforms globally.
Last month the European Parliament voted in favour of Article 13, a copyright law that will dramatically impact the global digital content industry. Anyone putting content onto social platforms anywhere in the world, from broadcasters to music labels to influencers, will be affected by this law and the resulting changes to social platforms. We’ve put together a summary and interviewed some leading experts and rights holders in Europe to get better educated on the issues.
What is Article 13?
Article 13 is part of the new EU Copyright Directive which aims to create copyright legislation appropriate for our current and future digital landscape. This Article deals specifically with “online content sharing services”, or those platforms where users have the ability to upload content that they may or may not own the rights to. Examples would be YouTube, Facebook, Instagram and audio platforms like Soundcloud. The aim is to address long held concerns from traditional rights holders who own and distribute content like TV, film, music and sport, who have seen social platforms grow, in part, from unauthorised uploads of their content.
Right now if a rights holder wants to send a copyright infringement notice for unauthorised use of their content on a social platform they would send it to the uploader. Once Article 13 is implemented those infringement claims will all go to the platform that is hosting the content, and the platform will take on all liability.
Traditional Rights Holders
Traditional rights holders have been one of the main groups instrumental in pushing through the changes to legislation and in the main it does sound like a positive step for them. Social platforms will now need to license all content from rights holders in the same way that a broadcaster would. This means that rights holders can build in negotiated licenses with platforms to their distribution deals or simply choose to block all content.
In addition, the new law gives a perceived increase in power to these rights holders over the social channels who repeatedly upload unauthorised versions of their content. Ollie Lewis, Head of Broadcast at Premiership Rugby (UK) is positive about the change. “We have numerous conversations with the rugby platforms and their social channels about their unauthorised use of our content … it could be good news for us in our dealings with them and in protecting our official licensees and broadcast partners across the globe.”
On YouTube, the day to day workflow for larger traditional rights holders is unlikely to change. This group generally already have access to YouTube’s sophisticated system called ContentID which fingerprints their videos and auto-matches them with unauthorised uploads. Once matched, they can choose whether to block, track or monetise this content. But smaller rights holders might find it harder to get their content onto YouTube.
We spoke to Nick Savage, SVP Digital Monetisation & Strategy at NBCUniversal who helped to explain. “For IP owners who use ContentID not much will change – they still get to decide what happens – but for those that don’t, then the platforms are going to have to either take on the risk or block content they believe might be infringing.”
No one really knows how this is going to work right now and numerous rumours of a secret trust score or safety ranking have started to surface. There could become a need for platforms to rank their contributors by how trustworthy they are in order to allow some content onto the platform immediately. Those less trusted uploaders could see their content blocked; either temporarily while checks are made or permanently if it is found to be infringing.
Again, this sounds great for the large traditional rights holders doesn’t it? Nic Yeeles, CEO of Influencer marketing software company peg.co advises caution. “The irony of it all is that whilst the world—including the very individuals and organisations who pushed through Article 13—are trying to break up the big tech giants and remove some of their power, the inverse might actually happen. Building sophisticated enough content ID systems is such an incredibly cost-prohibitive endeavour, that only the tech giants will have the resources to build them”. Platforms requiring a similar solution will then need to license the software from these companies.
Content Creators and Influencers
YouTube released a video in early March stating that despite some softening to the language in the Article prior to the vote, they believed it would “still hurt, not help, European creators”. In the same video they state that there is ambiguity in the wording and that the Article “will result in online platforms like YouTube blocking content because they need to remain on the side of caution and reduce their legal risks.”
So it is likely that platforms will feel forced to exercise caution and block untrustworthy content prior to upload in order to avoid being in receipt of millions of copyright claims. In theory, if you own 100% of your content you have nothing to worry about. There may simply be a delay to the publish date or maybe no change at all. Nick Savage said “If I were to advise an influencer on what to do, I’d say absolutely avoid using any 3rd party content in your videos, it’s the simplest way to ensure no problems”. Things get a bit more complicated when you start to think about music and audio tracks, clips, trailers and memes. For example no one is currently clear on how content that would have previously fallen under ‘Fair Use’ like parody, news and criticism will be dealt with post Article 13.
We asked Si Barbour-Brown, head of UK talent management company The Sharper Group what advice he is giving content creators on his roster about future-proofing their channels. Si said: “As a… company that works with large clients regularly, we’d only ever use license free music in content and also have any big brands and studios white-list or release claims on any trailers or imagery they owned that we’d need for a specific post”.
This makes it unlikely that Sharper Group content will be blocked permanently, but there could still be delays to uploading unless these creators achieve a high score in the rumoured platform ranking systems. Si is supportive of the ranking of creators, and goes as far as to say “I strongly believe that all platforms should have ‘preferred’ creators/accounts that are made up of large companies and individual producers/influencers. This would definitely be a start in making it far easier to regulate who is permitted to use cleared and authorised content.”
Why is this a global issue?
Content sharing platforms will need to make technical and workflow changes in order to implement the legal changes that Article 13 dictates. It is highly unlikely that they will create a different version of their platform purely for the use of European creators and audiences. Nick Savage said “whilst this is an EU law the global platforms are tending to lean towards “the most conservative view” in terms of policy. So it wouldn’t surprise me if this was implemented globally.”
So changes are coming, and we will all feel the impact of these. Nic Yeeles warns the global industry “We have a couple of years for countries within the EU to implement the changes, and—much like GDPR—no one knows exactly how strictly enforced these regulations will be, or how severe the punishments will look for mishaps. But for countries outside of the EU not paying attention: it’s like seeing your neighbours’ house burn down and saying “Meh, it’s next door so we don’t need to worry about it”.”
It is clear that this change to EU law and the shifting burden of copyright liability onto platforms will force them to change the way that they interact with their users. These changes will have a far-reaching impact for anyone who uploads content to the internet regardless of their territory. Article 13 should be firmly on our global industry agenda and inform all future content strategy.
Latest News
Mark Tompkins Adds Creative Power To Enthral
Storytelling agency Enthral has bolstered its creative offering with the addition of Creative Director Mark Tompkins. Tompkins joins the agency with more than 20 years of experience and a who’s who of agencies in Australia and London on his CV, including TBWA, DDB, Clemenger and Ogilvy. Until now, all of Enthral’s creative work has relied […]
Mat Baxter! Wippa! Tinder! – Epic Cannes in Cairns Sessions Locked In!
Cannes In Cairns is happening next week! So you need to read this & phone your travel agent at the same time.
Is Yoshi A Non-Binary Lesbian? The Good, The Bad & The Ugly Of Google AI Fails
Who doesn't love a good old technology stuff up story? Still, not quite as funny as when humans do something similar.
TV Ratings (29/05/2024): Seven’s The 1% Club UK Tops Wednesday Night Prime Time
Tune into Seven's 1% Club last night to hear contestants saying "chimney sweep, guv'nor"? It was the UK version.
Apple’s Latest Ad Makes Animators The Star
Adland loves to drag out the old "drink from the Kool-Aid" maxim. And it still seems appropriate for Apple users.
‘Significant Breaches Are Too Common’ – Millions Of Aussies’ Data Could Be Under Threat In Ticketmaster Hack
As concerning as these data breaches are, B&T very worried our lives aren't that interesting to the Russian hackers.
Majority Of Aussies Want Privacy Over Personalisation As Optus & Medibank Data Breach Fallout Revealed
Study shows online privacy remains a huge concern for many Aussies. Still very open for any two-for-one pizza deals.
The Monkeys Nab Creative Directors From Goodby Silverstein & Partners
Having The Monkeys on your resume will do no creative any harm. As will having a certificate in CPR and fire safety.
‘Life Is Too Short For Your Work To Not Have A Positive Impact On Society’: The Tall Planner, Kate Smither Chats With Fernando Machado
Kate Smither & Fernando Machado chat having a positive impact on society. How could we possibly joke about that?
Cristiano Ronaldo Tries To Resurrect NFTs With Binance Collection
Never really got the whole NFTs thing? Thought they were dead anyway? Let Ronaldo's perfect jaw persuade you otherwise.
Samsung Ads & Nielsen Study: Allocate 30% Of Total TV Budget To Streaming
Study urges marketers to allocate 30% of budgets to streaming. Not to say the rest should be spent on dire flash mobs.
Mindshare & Avid Collective Highlight Reef Conservation Efforts In New Pro-Bono Campaign For Citizens of the Reef
It's the duty of all Aussies to help protect the Reef. Not so the Big Pineapple or Madame Tussauds at Darling Harbour.
Dentsu: Australian Ad Spend Slowly Growing
Dentsu predicts local ad growth to fall behind the global average.
First Nations Art Takes Over oOh!media 3D Anamorphic Billboard In Melbourne’s CBD
The Melbourne CBD treated to cool new 3D anamorphic billboard amid cries of "I've been anamorphiced & I love it."
News Corp Australia Restructures Business
You know when Lachlan's in town it's rarely going to be good news. Unless you call a large redundancy cheque good news.
Olympics Set To Lose Keys To Major Sponsorship Deal After Paris
Let's hope this sponsor exodus doesn't continue or the Brisbane's 2032 Games might end up at Coorparoo Bowls Club.
Foxcatcher Launches WorldView Retail, Predicting Customer Lifetime Value
New tech can help marketers predict a customer's lifetime value. As does smoking cigarettes & too many KFC Zingers.
LiSTNR & DataCo Technologies Partner To Accelerate Its Data Cleanroom Strategy
LiSTNR unveils its new data cleanroom solutions. So get ready to get down and data dirty with this report.
Canteen Australia Appoints UM As Media Agency Of Record
Often use the expressions "it ain't rocket science" or "it's hardly curing cancer"? Well, today UM is curing cancer.
Anytime Fitness Launches “Find Your Fit” Audio Campaign, Via The Hallway
As winter sets in, we could all do with some prodding to get to the gym. Unlike Uber Eats, where no prodding's required.
Spotlight On Sponsors: Eels Latest Deal Leaves NRL Fans Divided
There's no greater disaster for a brand than killing its own customers. So, you gotta admire Hardies' resurrection here.
Paramount’s Beverley McGarvey On Diversity, Authenticity & Respect Across The Board
A proud Irishwoman, McGarvey has one of media's most important gigs. Yet no plans for Guinness pie recipes on MasterChef.
Redefining Brand For The Mobile Age: Jay Morgan Launches POPULA
New agency aims to tap into a "mobile-first world". Well, that is until Elon implants microchips into all our brains.
Ash Barty & Michael Hooper Among Sport Superstars Joining Stan Olympic Coverage
First he misses the World Cup & then the Olympic Seven's, so you have to admire Michael Hooper's determination here.
TV Ratings (28/05/2024): Aussies Tune In To Watch Ava Being Ousted On The Summit
As much as B&T enjoys Nine's The Summit, we felt Sylvester Stallone's 'Cliffhanger' had a far better eviction process.
Leading Brands And Agencies To Share Insights In Boomtown MasterClass, Following Brand Success In Regional Australia
Look no further than the value of regional areas than these testimonials. Or listen to Icehouse's Great Southern Land.
Richard And Christian Wilkins Delve Into The Family Dynamics Of Well-Loved Celebs In New Podcast
Best known for his brazen fashion sense, Christian Wilkins joins dad Richard on this new & decidedly frock-free podcast.
Reconciliation Australia Launches National Reconciliation Week Campaign Via Carbon Creative
Here's important work from Reconciliation Australia. Plus, there's no John Farnham songs or a trip to a polling booth.
Who Rules The Roost In Indie Agency Land? Best Of The Best Media Agency Leaders – Independent
In what was no easy task, B&T counts down the top 10 indie media CEOs.
The Benevolent Society Empowers Aussies To Live Life Their Way In Latest Brand Campaign
The Benevolent Society is much like the office clean freak - doing good for everyone, just without the obvious OCD.
Nine Metro Mastheads Launch Get Fit Content Series With Colonial First State
Nine's mastheads to ramp up its financial advice beyond two-minute noodles & moving back in with your parents.
Married At First Sight New Zealand Returns To 9Now
You can now watch MAFS New Zealand on 9Now. Although the media company probably has bigger problems at the moment.
Shark Tank’s Sabri Suby Ranks Influencer E-Commerce Businesses To See What Businesses Can Learn To Do (And Not Do)
Who hasn't dreamed of chucking it all in for their own ecommerce business? Here's tips for picking a stud from a dud.
Rising Festival Partners With News Corp To Revive mX Newspaper
Melbourne commuters to be given free mystery media platform from last century. Yes, print returns for a short time.
Carsales & Sydney Swans Launch First Collaborative Ad Campaign
Carsales teams with the top-of-the-table Swans in latest campaign. Also cue the bandwagon jumping Sydney supporters.
Porsche Reviews Creative Agency
Nothing says "midlife crisis" like a Porsche, does it? Or for men who can't afford one - the ill-thought-out ponytail.